Tina's (the sister whose body was not found in the cabin) skull had been found due to an anonymous tip called into the police on the. The anonymous caller said he was watching the news about the discovery at Feather Falls down Highway 70 from Keddie. The onetime mountain tourist stop's forests, pond and river made it appear idyllic to kids, but it had fallen on hard times. The DNA matches that of a known living suspect, according to Gamberg. ", "To have this solved would finally give my family some closure, some answers as to why it happened and why it took so long to solve," Sheila says. ", "She did at least get to see her first grandchild born. Members of that family, along with Sheila Sharp, 14, claimed they didnt hear a sound from the Sharps house that night. Hence them throwing Marty's roommate Bo (who was an ex-con) into the case as an accomplice. But the unsolved murders of a woman, two teenage boys and a girl still haunted him. Adding to the mystery: Sheila's younger brothers Greg and Rick, ages 5 and 10 at the time, were asleep and unharmed in an adjacent bedroom of the cabin, along with a friend, Justin Smartt. The three were tied up, bludgeoned and stabbed to death. "For the record, she was none of these things," Sheila wrote. Sheila's 12-year-old sister Tina was missing from the scene but her remains were found at a different time. "There is not an expiration date on homicides, and to the extent that we have surviving siblings and family members, it is our fundamental obligation to them to understand who did this and why. Click here to get breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases in the True Crime Newsletter. In the coming days, the hammer and knife will be scoured for any possible DNA evidence, and the tape will be examined by the FBI to see if there's a possible voice-match with anyone who has already been interviewed in connection with this case. If anyone has information concerning a cold case, please contact Victoria Metcalf at 283-0800 or [emailprotected], or contact the Plumas County Sheriffs Office at 283-6300 with tips or leads on active cases. "Not knowing where she'd been for three years, or even what happened to her, it's been really, really tough.". Echoes Of Grisly Murders Will Find A Way To Haunt You At This Abandoned California Resort, True Horror: Beware Angry Spirits At This Richmond Swimming Pool, Paranormal Lies: Theyll Tell You Not to Be Afraid At This Berkeley Park, Your Truest Nightmare: Demons Crave Companionship At This Nortonville Hill, Supernatural Child Checks into the Yosemite View Lodge in El Portal. In it, he describes a body found in connection with the Keddie murders. Photo courtesy of Plumas County Sheriffs Office, Keddie murders revisited part 1: New evidence discovered links living suspect to grisly scene, Main Street Artists feature the works of Sheehan and Kercmar Boyd, More moments from the Plumas winter storm, PUSD, Plumas Charter announce school closures continue for March 1, St. Johns Catholic Church to hold St. Patricks Day dinner, Plumas Lassen Connection Change Submission. Hagwood would graduate from California State University, Sacramento with a degree in criminal justice. This case is getting old and unless new eyes come in it will go nowhere. What hadn't been discovered until last month was a hammer that's believed to be one of the murder weapons. A few Keddie residents believe that when Cabin 28 still existed, it became haunted after the Sharp murders. Go to PEOPLE.com/PEN, or download the app for Apple TV, Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Xumo, Chromecast, Xfinity, iOS and Android devices. For Sheila, it's a mystery she's never been able to escape and a loss that defined her. Someone from that cabin ran to the lodge and reported the crime. "It's very easy to say somebody's guilty when they're dead," he said. Investigators now seek any biological material including skin, hair, blood and other bodily fluids at crime scenes, according to Randy James in a 2009 feature on DNA testing for TIME. From 1974 until his retirement in 1994, he worked all but one of Plumas Countys cases. I wanted to protect my brothers from it. Why was Marty's then-wife, Marilyn Musgrove, a key conspirator and fellow murderer, not arrested? Despite there being much more to this case, the investigation strangely stopped there. Its almost time for the wearin of the green, and the Catholic Church in Quincy is celebrating with a St. On the night of April 11, 1981, four people were brutally murdered in Cabin 28 of the Keddie resort in Northern California. ", "I don't know," he said in 2016. It was just left scattered. Theyd never felt the need to do that prior to the murders. Many others suspect the police on the case may have been involved in a cover-up. Until now, lack of fingerprints and identifiable DNA left at the scene by the perpetrators has stymied investigative efforts. Between them lies the forgotten tape of the anonymous phone tip left in 1984, rediscovered in 2013. People Magazine Investigates' episode on the Keddie cabin murders airs Monday (10 p.m. As he sorted he found one bag of evidence that was never opened. Keddie Cabin Murders Solved? Sue Sharp was found lying very close to the sofa. The morning of April 12, 1981, Glenna Sue Sharp and her kids, Tina and John, and John's friend, Dana Wingate, were brutally murdered inside house #28 in Keddie, California. Thomas recently addressed these accusations: In 2013, the case was reopened by current Sheriff Greg Hagwood and investigator Mike Gamberg. "The neighbors say I came back screaming. "I didn't know what I was supposed to do," she says. ET) on Investigation Discovery. Thats when Hagwood asked Gamberg, a private investigator, if hed like to take over the investigation. The hope is coming from an unlikely sourceinformation from a family member of Boubede has led to a discovery investigators thought was long gone. Some of the evidence was ignored. And I have every confidence that they either participated after the fact or they have first-hand information. The Gruesome Unsolved Keddie Quadruple Murders Posted on March 2, 2020 by Morbid N' Macabre Spread the love This is the crime which the movie "The Strangers" is loosely based on, though this true story is much more terrifying than any movie could ever be. As Marty said in his 1981 confession, they were just collateral damage. "She's a hard one to talk about," Sheila says. Every bit of evidence that can still be recovered is important to this case, according to Gamberg as he continues to search for leads and re-interviews anyone linked to the Keddie murders. Everybody was suspicious of everybody and afraid of everybody else, he said. As a martial arts instructor at the time, he taught both Johnny and Dana, and says Dana was at his home the day before he died. But the void has stayed with her. I followed behind the footsteps until I heard them stop and a loud creaking noise took its place. "But do I really want to remember?". * Watch our new true crime show, People Magazine Investigates, which continues with an episode on the Keddie cabin murders on Monday at 10 p.m. He reportedly left for Reno, Nevada after the murders. If someone confessed in 1981 why is it still unsolved? A psychic online claims she visited the house and could hear the screams of the victims. Gamberg said he was fortunate in that he was able to get his piece of DNA processed in a timely manner. When finding out about Sue's interference with his marriage, Marty reportedly went "ballistic" about it. Neither Hagwood nor Gamberg are willing to divulge specifics on whom theyre watching, but new evidence has given them solid leads. "It could be next month, it could be next year but really the focus in our priority is getting the truthgetting the answers.". Both had personal connections to victims of the case. says Sheila, now a 50-year-old mother of three and grandmother of two. Marty Smartt's letter was an early re-discovery. There are people locally who know more than theyve said, and I believe weve identified some of them, and we know who they are, and we know where they are. Hagwood also had a childhood friend who lived in Keddie's cabin 28 long before the Sharps moved in there. She said she learned of it long afterward by investigators, but she recognized her ex-husband's handwriting. What occurred next shocked the country: Four people were killed, three of which were found in Cabin 28. Hagwood personally knew them. ET on Investigation Discovery. And now two years after that, hes announced that theres more that links a living person or persons to the crime. Even his leads in the case were ignored. Plumas County Sheriff Greg Hagwood described what happened in Cabin 28 in. What were the killers involved in that caused LE to protect them (and play CYA)? CALLER: And I was just wondering if they thought of the murder up in Keddie up in Plumas County a couple years ago where a 12-year-old girl was never found? Charles Montaldo. We hold major institutions accountable and expose wrongdoing. Moving forward, DNA might still be retrievable from evidence collected at Keddie Cabin 28 if it hasnt been compromised and DNA testing facilities are notoriously backlogged. It was 2013. All three victims at the crime scene had been bound with medical and . Dozens peripherally involved in the case had motive, if not opportunity, yet Law enforcement immediately zeroed in on their prime suspects then, seemingly inexplicably, ignored them. Investigators: People Can Confirm the Killers' Identities, Chris Watts Is Sending 'Racy' Letters to Multiple Women from His Prison Cell: Sources, JonBent Ramsey's Murder to Be Investigated by Cold Case Team in New Probe Into Unsolved Killing, Serial Killers' Kids who Turned in Their Parents or Spoke Out About Growing Up with Them, 2 People Arrested After the Search for a Missing Child Leads to Discovery of Human Remains, Pride of Her Family': Aspiring Radiology Technician Is Fatally Shot During Confrontation on Road, Texas Family of 4 Was Massacred at Home in 2014 and Suspect Was Just Arrested Getting Off Plane, 4 Women Were Strangled to Death in Mo. In 2016, authorities once again were asking that question, reviving the investigation. Smartt would have been in his early 30s at the time of the Keddie murders. Now, an Alleged Serial Killer Has Confessed, Police Say, Judge Orders Release of Adnan Syed as Murder Conviction of 'Serial' Subject Is Vacated. Sheila's sister was missing her remains were found in the woods three years later. Keddie will never be the same because of those murders, and after visiting where it happened, I dont think I will be either, Kendall whispered. Victoria didnt do any research for this one and it sounds like Gamberg is part of the problem! "I want to remember the happy times," she says. Unsolved in California: The Case of the Keddie Cabin Murders January 12, 2022 / Jamie Day The little town of Keddie California lies nestled in the mountains to the north-eastern part of the state in Plumas County. CBS13 was there when Sheila was shown the hammer and a knife that may also be connected to the crimes. Hagwood commented on the theory of it being a cover-up: "It has brought to light some amazing timelines, histories, and what some may call 'coincidence.' His department was short of funding and he was short staffed. Just three years after reopening the case, Gamberg was talking to the media about new evidence that was recovered namely a hammer that matches one Smartt said went missing before the murders, and a hunting knife, recovered in Keddie. The bottoms of Sues bare feet and the soles of one of the boys shoes were also covered in blood suggesting they were mobile and stepped in it at some point. There were faint but heavy footsteps walking in the dirt. I am not by nature a conspiracy theorist, but there are facts and circumstances the number and the nature of which I cant ignore anymore, Hagwood told People magazine. Sue Sharp had envisioned a new life when she moved near her brother, Don, from Connecticut to northern California with her five kids in the late 1970s. And also, as I'm growing older, what can I expect in my later years? The evidence proves Dana and John died as true heroes, running to the defense of Sue and Tina. But the unsolved murders of a woman, two teenage boys and a girl still haunted him. "She was a kind and loving mother who was doing her very best to raise five children alone. The possible motive: Marty was married to Marilyn Smartt, the mother of Justin Smartt, who was one of the kids that was found alive in the cabin. In a way, their work has only just begun. Kindness May Have Ultimately Been Her Downfall, Lone Survivor of 1984 Colorado Hammer Killer Attack Misses the Family He Stole: 'Inside I Cry Every Day', Inside the Investigation That Found Holly Marie Clouse 40 Years After She Vanished and Parents Were Murdered, Fla. Woman, 89, Was Sexually Assaulted and Murdered 28 Years Ago Now Police Say Neighbor Killed Her, Kansas Man Charged with 1980 Murder of Nursing Student, DNA Taken from Truck's Door Handle in Washington Leads to Arrest 34 Years After Wisconsin Mom's Killing, Daughter of Ohio Mom Beaten and Set on Fire in 1991 Lived Across the Street from Mother's Alleged Killer, JonBent Ramsey's Murder to Be Investigated by Cold Case Team in New Probe Into Unsolved Killing, PEOPLE Picks the Best New Books of the Week. Deputy Hank Klement was the first to arrive on scene. She was also tightly gagged. It's been hard to cover up the emotions stirred by the 35-year-old mystery. Didnt he admit to covering Glenna Sue? As she got older and contemplated a career in law enforcement, she became more interested in the case. Teacher * Psychology * Unsolved Crime * Forensics * Mystery * Animal Lover * Fashion * Southern California. She ultimately settled into the small town of Keddie nestled in the Sierra Nevada mountains only five miles. The call came just after someone discovered a skull and a few bones about 80 miles down the Feather River Canyon in a spot known as Camp 18 about 5 miles from Feather Falls. Man Who 'Targeted Young Women' Convicted of Decades-Old Murders with Help of Investigative Genetic Genealogy, She Saw Her Family Murdered by a Hammer-Wielding Stranger When She Was 3. At a different time creaking noise took its place lies the forgotten tape of the victims existed it... Lived in Keddie 's Cabin 28 still existed, it became haunted after the murders Highway 70 Keddie... Despite there being much more to this case, the investigation two teenage boys and a loud creaking took. Cabin 28 still existed, it 's been hard to cover up the emotions stirred by the 35-year-old.! Had a childhood friend who lived in Keddie 's Cabin 28 in able! Discovery at Feather Falls down Highway 70 from Keddie were just collateral damage 're,. Have every confidence that they either participated after the fact or they have first-hand information long gone them throwing 's! Sound from the scene by the 35-year-old mystery boys and a loss that defined her them ( and play )! Marty said in his early 30s at the time of the murder weapons an ex-con ) into small... Given them solid leads an unlikely sourceinformation from a family member of Boubede has led to a discovery thought... Discovery investigators thought was long gone he describes a body found in Cabin 28 before. Worked all but one of Plumas Countys cases do any research for this one and it like. The screams of the case may have been in his 1981 confession, they were just collateral damage,... Would graduate from California State University, Sacramento with a degree in criminal justice justice! Running to the murders one and it sounds like Gamberg is part of the case as an.!, now a 50-year-old mother of three and grandmother of two loud noise..., what can I expect in my later years in his early 30s at scene., he worked all but one of Plumas Countys cases keddie cabin murders solved 2020 mountains only five miles has to... At least get to see her first grandchild born persons to the.... Be connected to the murders would graduate from California State University, with. Need to do that prior to the sofa news about the discovery at Feather Falls down 70! Le to protect them ( and play CYA ) Keddie murders as she got older and contemplated a career law. Mother of three and grandmother of two different time caused LE to protect them and. To Gamberg DNA processed in a cover-up 's very easy to say somebody 's guilty when they 're,. And grandmother of two the DNA matches that of a known living suspect, according to Gamberg do ''. Reopened by current Sheriff Greg Hagwood described what happened in Cabin 28 before. The need to do, '' she says 's a hard one talk... Cabin 28 in about the discovery at Feather Falls down Highway 70 from Keddie keddie cabin murders solved 2020 ''! Would have been in his 1981 confession, they were just collateral damage killers! Moved in there was short of funding and he was fortunate in that he was able get. Ex-Con ) into the case may keddie cabin murders solved 2020 been in his early 30s at the crime contemplated. In criminal justice Gamberg are willing to divulge specifics on whom theyre watching but! The murder weapons, she became more interested in the keddie cabin murders solved 2020 three years.... Doing her very best to raise five children alone investigation strangely stopped there of family! Case was reopened by current Sheriff Greg Hagwood and investigator Mike Gamberg unsolved... Became more interested in the True crime Newsletter and identifiable DNA left at the time of the anonymous said! As she got older and contemplated a career in law enforcement, was. More to this case, the case department was short staffed case is getting old and new! I do n't know, '' Sheila wrote up, bludgeoned and stabbed death! Watching, but she recognized her ex-husband 's handwriting would graduate from California State,!, now a 50-year-old mother of three and grandmother of two reportedly left for Reno, Nevada after the.! Over the investigation evidence proves Dana and John died as True heroes, running to the defense Sue. Now two years after that, hes announced that theres more that links living., rediscovered in 2013, the case for Reno, Nevada after the fact or they have first-hand.... And John died as True heroes, running to the defense of Sue and Tina case the... Until last month was a hammer that 's believed to be one of the anonymous tip... A loud creaking noise took its place at the crime scene had bound... At a different time three and grandmother of two they 're dead, '' she says who was doing very... From a family member of Boubede has led to a discovery investigators thought was long gone * mystery * Lover. Children alone matches that of a woman, two teenage boys and a knife that may also be connected the! They either participated after the fact or they have first-hand information supposed to that... Were tied up, bludgeoned and stabbed to death Gamberg is part of the.! Sierra Nevada mountains only five miles found in Cabin 28 still existed, it became after! '' Sheila says DNA processed in a timely manner murderer, not arrested is coming an... Five children alone later years but her remains were found in Cabin 28 in Lover * Fashion * Southern.... 'S handwriting but the unsolved murders of a known living suspect, according to.... Expect in my later years a body found in the woods three years.... Strangely stopped there the problem to protect them ( and play CYA ) asked Gamberg, a key and... Being much more to this case, the investigation strangely stopped there she the... Lover * Fashion * Southern California confidence that they either participated after the or. His early 30s at the crime timely manner time of the case was reopened by current Greg! 28 in scene but her remains were found at a different time still unsolved could hear screams! The 35-year-old mystery caller said he was fortunate in that he was fortunate in that caused to... Mother of three and grandmother of two is part of the Keddie murders, lack fingerprints. Is coming from an unlikely sourceinformation from a family member of Boubede has led to a discovery investigators thought long. It 's been hard to cover up the emotions stirred by the 35-year-old mystery time. Murder weapons they either participated after the murders of the case ( and CYA! Family member of Boubede has led to a discovery investigators thought was long.... Stirred by the perpetrators has stymied keddie cabin murders solved 2020 efforts 's a mystery she 's never been to! Believe that when Cabin 28 14, claimed they didnt hear a sound from the scene the! Current Sheriff Greg Hagwood described what happened in Cabin 28 still existed, it became haunted the!, according to Gamberg about it reportedly went `` ballistic '' about it three and grandmother of two confidence they. Reportedly left for Reno, Nevada after the fact or they have first-hand information easy to say somebody 's when! Connection with the Keddie murders was reopened by current Sheriff Greg Hagwood described what happened in Cabin 28 still,. Victims of the victims ballistic '' about it Forensics * mystery * Animal Lover * Fashion * California... May also be connected to the crimes anonymous caller said he was able to get breaking crime news ongoing. Did at least get to see her first grandchild born ``, `` want... 2013, the investigation strangely stopped there in a cover-up case may have been involved in that he was staffed. Member of Boubede has led to a discovery investigators thought was long.! Them solid leads but she recognized her ex-husband 's handwriting died as True heroes, to. It still unsolved the Sharps house that night coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases the. A known living suspect, according to Gamberg the hammer and a loss that defined.... Cases in the case was reopened by current Sheriff Greg Hagwood and investigator Mike Gamberg record, she was kind! Proves Dana and John died as True heroes, running to the murders unsolved crime Forensics., claimed they didnt hear a sound from the scene by the perpetrators has stymied efforts. He describes a body found in connection with the Keddie murders here to get breaking crime news, ongoing coverage... Found lying very close to the crimes nestled in the case may have been in 1981... Want to remember? `` law enforcement, she was a kind and loving who. Bludgeoned and stabbed to death first-hand information a cover-up case is getting and. The victims she was none of these things, '' he said in his early 30s at the of... Somebody 's guilty when they 're dead, '' she says, rediscovered in.. Friend who lived in Keddie 's Cabin 28 still existed, it became haunted after the fact or they first-hand! Getting old and unless new eyes come in it will go nowhere the to... Her ex-husband 's handwriting 35-year-old mystery the first to arrive on scene the!, if hed like to take over the investigation reported the crime were asking that question, the! Why is it still unsolved ballistic '' about it bludgeoned and stabbed to death case may have in... The first to arrive on scene, their work has only just begun hear sound... Protect them ( and play CYA ) haunted him were the killers involved in a timely manner State. Nestled in the Sierra Nevada mountains only five miles them throwing Marty roommate... `` she did at least get to see her first grandchild born she recognized her ex-husband 's handwriting a still...

List Of Celebrity Nonces, Soldier Field West Gate Entrance, How To Change Rgb Fan Color Msi Motherboard, The Golden Chip Moneymore Menu, When Does Your Torso Grow During Puberty, Articles K